Nicolo's Restaurant

Experience authentic Italian flavors at Nicolo's Restaurant in Chaffee, NY. Enjoy delicious pizza, chicken Alfredo, fish fry, beef on weck, wings, subs, and more. Call +1 716-496-5666!

Welcome to Nicolo's Restaurant

Taste the Difference.

Nicolo's Restaurant
Nicolo's Restaurant
Nicolo's Restaurant
Nicolo's Restaurant

Nestled at 12459 Olean Rd, Chaffee, NY, Nicolo's Restaurant serves as a beloved hub for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. The atmosphere buzzes with a warm, inviting ambiance, perfect for dining with family or friends. Nicolo's prides itself on offering a diverse menu, showcasing delicious options from Italian classics to hearty American fare. This cozy restaurant quickly fills up, particularly on a Friday evening, when the aroma of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air. With each bite, a culinary journey unfolds, highlighting the flavors that have made this spot a community favorite.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

12459 Olean Rd, Chaffee, NY 14030, United States

Phone

+1 716-496-5666

About

The Culinary Story

Nicolo's Restaurant
Nicolo's Restaurant
Nicolo's Restaurant
Nicolo's Restaurant

Since opening its doors, Nicolo's Restaurant has become more than just a dining spot; it’s a community landmark. The family-friendly environment invites diners to share meals and laughter, making it a gathering place for friends and families. The restaurant champions fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring every dish bursts with flavor. Traditional Italian recipes complement American comfort food cravings, providing a perfect fusion of tastes. Popular dishes include Chicken Parmigiana and the signature Garlic Parm Wings.

For those looking to explore different flavors, the daily specials and pizzas made to order allow for creative dining experiences. The restaurant welcomes a steady flow of newcomers and returning faces, fostering camaraderie among patrons. Regulars often share their favorites, creating an exciting exchange of culinary tips. The dinner rush peaks on Friday nights at 6 PM, making it an ideal time to call ahead for a table. But for those seeking quieter moments, late nights, particularly on weekdays, promise a more relaxed dining experience. Their friendly staff knows the menu inside and out, always ready to provide recommendations tailored to every palate.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday12-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4-8:30 PM
  • Wednesday4-8:30 PM
  • Thursday4-8:30 PM
  • Friday4-9:30 PM
  • Saturday4-9:30 PM

Nicolo's Restaurant boasts an extensive menu of 114 dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The highlights include their Chicken Alfredo Supreme, Fish Fry, and the famed Beef on Weck, which keep patrons coming back for more. Savor the Garlic Parm Wings or try the homemade Cobblers for dessert. Portions are generous, giving excellent value for your hard-earned dollars. Specialties like Taco Pizza and Chicken Finger Pizza provide delightful twists on traditional recipes.

Additionally, the kiddie menu accommodates younger diners with tasty options featuring pizza and spaghetti. Nicolo's also offers everyday specials—perfect for families gathering together. Vegetarian and gluten-free options appear, ensuring inclusivity for various dietary needs.

Nicolo's Restaurant

From the outside, Nicolo's Restaurant presents a charming facade that invites curiosity. The quaint building sits snugly along Olean Rd, easily recognizable with its warm signage. Outdoor seating options provide patrons a chance to enjoy their meals al fresco when the weather allows. The vibe here is casual yet bustling, with a mix of families, couples, and friends gathering to enjoy hearty meals. Laughter and conversation fill the air, creating a friendly atmosphere that encourages guests to stay a while longer. This engaging environment makes Nicolo's a favorite spot for both locals and visitors alike.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Absolutely amazing food, the best Italian in the area. Prices are great and the service was lovely. They have a good selection of beer and wine. The menu is huge and they have a ton of options if you're not sure what to eat.

G
Griffin A.

I have gotten takeout lately but even their dine in was great last time I was there. Pizza is just really really good. Leftovers are very good.

J
Jerry D.

The food was amazing, and so was the service. We had 2 waitresses (one was in training), and our service was great. The owner came out and said, "Hi," to the people he knew. It was a very friendly atmosphere. Will definitely go again!

J
Jennifer S.

Great quality food,huge portions, and pre-COVID prices. Staff was very friendly too.

M
Matt D.

I have to say the pizza is the best in WNY.My husband and I grew up in this area and everytime we come out here from West Seneca,we grab. a pizza..Absolutely the best.

C
Connie A.

NY pizza and wings. The hot aren't too hot and when you order extra crispy you don't have to complain or send them back.

J
Joshua R.